Skip to content
YANINAGAMES

What Is the Best GTA? Four Honest Answers

What Is the Best GTA? The Answer Changes Completely Depending on What You Measure

Ask this in any forum, and you’ll get a fight. Ask it with data, and you get something stranger: four defensible answers that don’t agree with each other at all. Critics picked one game of the GTA series. Players bought a different one in numbers nothing else comes close to. The community keeps crowning a third. And the game you should actually start with is arguably a fourth. Two days before GTA 6 lands and potentially scrambles all of it, here’s the honest state of the argument – with the numbers behind each answer, and my own verdict at the end.

Answer One: The Critics Say GTA IV

By review score, there’s no debate at all. Grand Theft Auto IV holds a 98 on Metacritic from 86 critic reviews, and that’s not just the series record – it’s one of the highest-scored games ever made, tied with SoulCalibur and Super Mario Galaxy 2 for second place all-time behind Ocarina of Time’s 99.

Game Year Metascore
Grand Theft Auto IV 2008 98
Grand Theft Auto III 2001 97
Grand Theft Auto V 2013 97
GTA: San Andreas 2004 95
GTA: Vice City 2002 95
Grand Theft Auto 2 1999 70
GTA Advance 2004 68

First, every mainline entry since GTA III has scored 95 or above. That’s a run almost nothing in the medium can match, and it’s why GTA 6’s reviews tomorrow carry such an absurd weight – for context, the highest-rated game of 2026 so far is the Ocarina of Time remake at 95. A score in the low 90s would be extraordinary for almost any game and still the worst mainline GTA of the modern era.

Second, scores move by platform in ways that complicate the story. GTA IV’s PC port scored 90, eight points below the console versions. GTA V reads 97 on PS3, Xbox 360, PS4 and Xbox One, 96 on PC – but 81 on PS5 and 79 on Xbox Series X, where critics reviewed a decade-old re-release on its own merits rather than against 2013’s field.

So even the “objective” answer needs an asterisk about which version you’re counting.

Answer Two: The Sales Say GTA V, Overwhelmingly

If popularity is your metric, this isn’t close either – it’s just a different winner.

Game Copies Sold
Grand Theft Auto V 230 million+
GTA: San Andreas ~27.5 million
Grand Theft Auto IV ~25 million
GTA: Vice City ~17.5 million
Grand Theft Auto III ~14.5 million
Liberty City Stories ~11 million
Vice City Stories ~6 million

GTA V has sold roughly nine times what GTA IV managed. It accounts for about half of the franchise’s 470 million lifetime total on its own, and sits among the best-selling video games ever released, behind Minecraft.

A couple of honest caveats on those numbers. Take-Two reports “sold-in” figures – copies shipped to retailers and digital storefronts, not copies bought by players. And the company no longer breaks out sales for GTA III, Vice City, San Andreas or GTA IV individually, so the older figures come from historical disclosures rather than current reporting.

Worth noting San Andreas’s placement too: second in the series, and the best-selling PlayStation 2 game ever made. On the hardware it launched on, nothing outsold it.

The obvious objection to the sales metric is that GTA V has had thirteen years, three console generations and GTA Online’s revenue engine to accumulate that figure. True – but it’s also still selling in the millions per quarter, which says something no review score can.

What Is the Best GTA

Answer Three: The Community Says, San Andreas

Here’s where it gets messy, because community consensus isn’t measured; it’s argued.

Spend any time in GTA threads and the pattern is unmistakable: San Andreas appears as “best in the series” more often than anything else, usually on the strength of scope. Three cities rather than one. A whole state. Swimming, gyms, character stats, jets, jetpacks. It nearly doubled Vice City’s story length, going from roughly 16.5 hours to around 30.

Vice City’s defenders counter with atmosphere and soundtrack, and they’re rarely challenged on either point – the 1986 Miami setting and its radio stations are the series’ most distinctive aesthetic achievement, and Tommy Vercetti remains a favourite.

GTA IV’s camp argues story and character. Niko Bellic gets named as the best protagonist in the series regularly, the Euphoria physics engine is still described as a technical marvel, and Liberty City gets called one of the most detailed city environments ever built.

But the community is also self-aware about how circular this gets. One forum post sums up the series’ entire discourse history:

  • 2002: Vice City is bad, III is better.
  • 2004: San Andreas is bad, Vice City is better.
  • 2008: IV is bad, San Andreas is better.

Every GTA has been declared a disappointment on release and a classic five years later. Expect exactly the same cycle to begin on November 19.

There’s also a vocal counter-current arguing San Andreas hasn’t aged well – that the shooting is weird, the driving is clunky, and that people rank it on reputation rather than recent play. That criticism isn’t unreasonable, and it’s why “best” and “best to play today” aren’t the same question.

Answer Four: The One You Should Actually Play First

If you’ve never played a GTA and you want the shortest route to understanding why people care, the answer is GTA V – and it’s not really about quality.

It’s the only entry that still plays like a modern game without adjustment. The shooting, driving and mission design hold up because the HD-era design language hasn’t moved on much since. It’s available everywhere, it’s cheap, and the three-protagonist structure gives you variety without demanding investment.

More importantly, it’s the shared reference point. If you want to understand what the series means culturally, V is the one everyone else has played.

Start anywhere else, and you’re learning two things at once: the game, and how games used to work.

Why Critics and Players Disagree So Sharply About GTA IV?

The gap between IV’s 98 and its community standing is the most interesting thing in this whole argument, so it’s worth unpacking.

Critics in 2008 were reviewing a leap. Euphoria physics, a city with unprecedented density and incidental detail, a story with genuine tonal ambition, and console online multiplayer for a series that had never had it. On those terms, a 98 is defensible.

Players were reacting to what it removed. No planes. A heavier, more grounded tone after San Andreas’s gleeful absurdity. Driving physics that felt like work. Friends who phone you constantly. For a generation that had spent four years flying jets over three cities, Liberty City felt like a contraction.

What’s happened since is a slow critical rehabilitation. A widely circulated Crowbcat comparison video reignited appreciation for IV’s physics and detail relative to V, and GTA IV fandom has become its own visible faction – obnoxiously so, by the admission of people inside it.

My read: IV is the series’ artistic high point, and V is its most complete product. Those are different achievements and the scoreboard was never going to reconcile them.

Which GTA Is Best for What You Actually Want

The useful version of this question is narrower. Here’s how I’d route it:

  • Best overall package: GTA V. Mission design, world variety, replay value, and a thirteen-year content tail.
  • Best story and characters: GTA IV. Niko Bellic carries the series’ most coherent narrative.
  • Best atmosphere and soundtrack: Vice City. Nothing else in the series has a sense of place this strong.
  • Best scope and freedom: San Andreas. Three cities, stats, and the broadest sandbox of the 3D era.
  • Best historical importance: GTA III. It invented the modern formula, and its 97 reflects that.
  • Best if you’re new: GTA V, for the reasons above.
  • Best for ruining your free time entirely: GTA Online, which became its own era.

That list resolves more arguments than any single ranking, because most “best GTA” disputes are really people optimising for different things and not saying so.

The Games Nobody Mentions

Two entries get unfairly ignored in these conversations.

Liberty City Stories and Vice City Stories sold 11 million and 6 million respectively – figures most studios would build a franchise on – and Vice City Stories in particular gets cited by people who’ve actually played it as better than its reputation suggests.

Chinatown Wars is the series’ genuine oddity, a top-down handheld entry with a distinct art style that regularly turns up as a critical favourite despite almost nobody having played it.

Neither is the best GTA. But “best” conversations that pretend the handhelds don’t exist are missing a decade of the series.

What Happens to This Question After November 19

Everything above has a two-day shelf life, potentially.

GTA 6 launches on Thursday, November 19, with the review embargo reportedly lifting tomorrow, November 18. If it clears 98, it takes the critical crown outright. If it lands at 95 or 96, it joins the pack and the argument continues exactly as before. If it lands lower, that becomes the story regardless of how good the game is.

On sales, it’s already the most pre-ordered game in PlayStation and Xbox Store history, so the long-term sales answer will probably change eventually – though matching GTA V’s 230 million is a thirteen-year project, not a launch-week one.

The community answer will take about five years, if history is any guide. Going by the pattern above, GTA 6 gets called a disappointment in December and a masterpiece around 2031.

Our Actual Verdict

Forced to name one:

  • GTA V is the best GTA game, because “best” has to account for how well something works today, and V is the only entry that’s genuinely excellent on its own terms without historical allowances.
  • GTA IV is the best-made GTA game, and the 98 isn’t a fluke. It’s the most ambitious thing Rockstar built before Red Dead Redemption 2.
  • San Andreas is the most beloved, and that counts for something no metric captures.
  • Vice City is the one I’d replay first, which is a completely different question and probably the only honest answer any of us gives.

If that feels like a dodge, consider that the series has five entries scoring 95 or higher. A franchise where the “worst” modern game is a 95 doesn’t have a best. It has a spread of excellent games optimised for different things.

What Is the Best GTA

FAQ

What is the best GTA game by critic score?

GTA IV, with a 98 on Metacritic from 86 reviews – the highest in the series and among the highest-scored games ever released.

What is the best-selling GTA game?

GTA V by an enormous margin, with over 230 million copies sold-in as of Take-Two’s August 2026 report. San Andreas is second at roughly 27.5 million.

Which GTA do fans consider the best?

San Andreas appears most frequently in community rankings, usually for its scope. Vice City and GTA IV both have substantial support, and the debate has never settled.

Which GTA should I play first?

GTA V. It still plays like a modern game, it’s widely available, and it’s the shared cultural reference point.

Is GTA IV better than GTA V?

Critics scored it one point higher. Players bought V nine times more. IV has the better story, V the more complete package.

Has every GTA scored well?

Every mainline entry since GTA III has scored 95 or above on Metacritic. The older top-down games and GTA Advance scored considerably lower.

Will GTA 6 become the best GTA?

Reviews are expected November 18, a day before the November 19 launch. It needs to beat 98 to take the critical record.

The Argument Will Outlive Us All

What makes this question endure isn’t that nobody knows the answer. It’s that there are four correct answers and people keep picking one and defending it as though the others don’t exist.

Critics crowned IV. Buyers crowned V. The community keeps crowning San Andreas. And whichever one you played at fifteen is the one you’ll defend until you die, which is really what’s happening in every one of these threads.

Come back Thursday. There’ll be a new contender, and the cycle starts again.

If this settled – or productively escalated – an argument you’ve been having for years, pass it on: share it, bookmark it, fire it at whoever insists San Andreas holds up perfectly. And if you’ve got a creative or commercial project that deserves a 98, YaninaGames is taking review copies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *